Thistle flowers are very pretty, their light purple flowers contrasting with the bold, textured green of the leaves and branches of the plant. Unfortunately, the garden beds on the south side of the house, thick clay no matter how much I have mulched and dug in composted material, are rife with thistle plants, soon after the tulips have died back at the end of spring. I let the thistles grow for long enough that I can take photographs, and long enough that the bees can enjoy them while they wait for the hollyhocks to bloom.
My thistles don’t look like the thistles of Scotland that I see in photographs on the Internet. Mine are much more tame, less threatening.
I don’t recall from where in Scotland my ancestors immigrated to the United States, or when. I don’t think that’s a major part of my heritage, unless we’re thinking Celt, in which case the Irish and Welsh, as well as the Scottish ancestries are grouped together. I’ve Irish ancestry on both sides of the family. Berry, my mother’s side of the family, is Scottish and northern Irish, but it’s also a French name, and I do have people from France in my family tree. On my father’s side? His mother was Mary Elizabeth Murphy. Can’t get much more Irish than that!
My father and mother used to sing, we children joining in as soon as we were able, popular songs when we went on car trips, including “Who Threw the Overalls in Mistress Murphy’s Chowder”, “Danny Boy”, “When Irish Eyes Are Smiling”, and others. One of my favorites is Wearin’ of the Green (MP3 and lyrics). Another, a popular round, was “White Coral Bells.” I very much enjoyed singing…listening to our singing. The way the various voices wove together, the complexity of the intertwining melody and words layering over the phrase before and under the one that followed. The beauty was arresting.


That is a pretty thistle picture. {SMILE}
I have Scottish ancestors, too. I think they’re mostly from lowland Scotland, not too far from the border with England. It’s hard to be more specific. Some of them preferred not to be too easily traceable due to involvement with a failed revolution against the English. {Smile}
I’ve heard and sung most of those songs, but I’ve never heard the one about the overalls and the chowder. The title sounds funny. Now I’m curious about the words and tune. {Smile}
Anne Elizabeth Baldwin
I will have to check back in Mom’s book to find out whether we have any details or not.
Authentic rendition is here; I’ve got the sheet music, lyrics and accompaniment. My dad’s version is slightly different, but pretty close to this one.
Who threw the overalls in Mrs. Murphy’s chowder? (1901) –
http://www.archive.org/details/EDIS-SRP-0205-20
Who threw the overalls in Mrs. Murphy’s chowder?
Performed by: Edward M. Favor
Record format: Edison Concert cylinder
Release number: 7697
Release date: February 1901
NPS object catalog number: EDIS 24893